Tips and troncs – what does it mean for your business?

Since July, it has been illegal for employers to withhold tips from staff. The payment of tips will probably result in a national insurance contribution (NIC) cost for both employer and employees, but this extra cost can be circumvented if a tronc arrangement is used to distribute tips.

The new legislation applies mainly to those operating in the hospitality sector, and covers all tips, gratuities and service charges. It also brings the law into line with modern payment practices as it covers tips left via card payment.

NICs

Tips paid to employees are subject to both income tax and employee NICs. The NIC cost is at a rate of 8% where tips – when added to normal earnings – fall between £1,048 and £4,189 monthly. Employers pay NICs once a monthly threshold of £758 is reached, although their liability is normally reduced by the annual £5,000 employment allowance.

For example, if a restaurant pays out £25,000 worth of tips, the employer will probably be facing an additional NIC cost of nearly £3,500. The cost for the staff could be up to £2,000. This is where a tronc arrangement comes into play.

Troncs

A tronc is an arrangement used to distribute tips. It is run by a troncmaster.

Provided it is the troncmaster who decides how tips are to be distributed among staff, there are no employee or employer NICs on amounts paid out. It is still possible, however, for the tips to be included on the employer’s payroll.

The troncmaster will typically be a member of staff, although larger businesses might prefer to use the services of a specialist provider. There is no problem if the employer makes the decision on who to appoint as troncmaster; what is important is that the employer plays no part, directly or indirectly, in the allocation of tips.

HMRC’s detailed guidance on tips, gratuities, service charges and troncs can be found here.

Making way for E-invoicing

The government wants businesses to make more use of electronic invoicing to combat VAT fraud and enhance tax collection.

E-invoicing is where invoices are created, sent, received and processed in a digital format, with the e-invoice containing exactly the same information as a traditional invoice.

With more than half of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries having mandated e-invoicing, the UK is seriously lagging and even still allows paper invoices. The government plans to carry out a consultation, the details of which are scarce.

Benefits of e-invoicing

Even though UK mandation almost certainly remains some way off, you will probably need to use e-invoicing if your business operates internationally. Even if this is not the case, there are still benefits to early adoption:

  • With a standardised and structured format, e-invoices can be processed faster and with fewer errors. Invoices sent to a buyer can be tracked in real time, and the number of invoice rejections and disputes considerably reduced.
  • Duplicate invoices are avoided, and fraudulent activity will be largely prevented since it will not be possible to intercept invoices to change bank details.
  • Invoices, both sent and received, will be processed immediately, so cashflow forecasting will be improved and working capital requirements better managed. Faster payment of invoices received will ensure prompt payment discounts are taken advantage of.

Apart from the more obvious benefits, the relationship between buyer and supplier should improve, leading to higher customer retention and satisfaction.

Implementation of e-invoicing

Based on what has happened in other countries that have adopted e-invoicing, the implementation process can take at least three years. The usual approach is for a phased roll-out, with larger businesses required to comply first.

With mandatory e-invoicing likely for the UK, businesses should start preparing as early as possible. Rather than developing their own e-invoicing solution, many businesses will prefer to work with an e-invoicing service provider. Take care in the selection process to ensure that future e-business needs will be fully met.

Guidance on selecting the right e-invoicing service provider can be found here.

Caught in the 60% tax trap?

The number of taxpayers caught in the 60% tax trap has increased by nearly 25% over the past year. More than 500,000 people are now affected by higher tax rates due to their income exceeding £100,000.

The 60% rate applies to income between £100,000 and £125,140. This is the tranche of income which sees the £12,570 personal allowance tapered away.

Fiscal drag

There has been no change in the £100,000 income limit since the withdrawal of the personal allowance was introduced in 2010, a classic case of fiscal drag. Once the personal allowance is fully withdrawn, higher earners pay the additional rate of 45% on income in excess of £125,140. However, the 60% charge still applies to income between £100,000 and £125,140.

The past year has seen a particularly high increase in individuals caught by the 60% tax trap due to inflation driving up salaries. The government is unlikely to fix the problem by reinstating the personal allowance for higher earners – the cost would be prohibitive. However, smoothing the transition is a possibility. For example, tapering the personal allowance by £1 for every £4 (rather than £2) that income exceeds £100,000 would reduce the 60% tax rate to a rate of 50%.

Planning measures

Measures that can be taken to mitigate the 60% tax trap vary from individual to individual:

  • Pension contributions are particularly attractive if the government is funding 60% of the cost. Be warned, however, that the October Budget might see the tax relief given on pension contributions restricted to a flat rate.
  • Some income reallocations might be possible between spouses and civil partners, especially if they are in business together.
  • Make the best use of tax-free investments to turn taxable investment income into non-taxable income.
  • Be mindful of the timing when cashing in investment bonds or making pension withdrawals.

Employees should consider using a salary sacrifice arrangement for pension contributions or low-emission company cars.

Details of income tax rates and personal allowances for the current tax year can be found on the government website here.