Company cars are having a revival

Mileage

Recently published statistics show that the company car is making something of a comeback, with the number of recipients for 2023/24 up 80,000 from the previous year.

From a high of 960,000 company car recipients in 2015/16, the number dropped to 720,000 by 2020/21. The level has now picked up to 840,000, with the increase due to the beneficial tax treatment of cars with CO2 emissions of 75 grams per kilometre or less, especially fully electric cars.

Salary sacrifice

With tax thresholds frozen, sacrificing salary in return for the use of a low-emission company car can mean a significant tax saving. For example, an employee with an income of £120,000 – well within the personal allowance trap – who sacrifices £6,000 of salary to cover the employer’s lease cost of a mid-priced, fully electric company car, will save around £2,800 in tax and National Insurance Contributions. With this in mind:

  • It is therefore not surprising that the number of zero-emission company car recipients has risen six-fold between 2020/21 and 2023/24, with the number now standing at over 340,000. This is 41% of all company car benefit recipients.
  • It also explains why the average CO2 emission of company cars for 2023/24 was 56 g/km, compared to 71 g/km in the previous tax year.
  • A further advantage of an employee making use of a fully electric company car is that there will be no fuel benefit even if a charging point is provided at the employer’s premises.

The rise in fully electric company car recipients is mirrored in the percentage of company car drivers with diesel cars, which is down to 13%, having been nearly 50% back in 2020/21.

The future                            

While fully electric company cars currently attract a benefit percentage of just 3%, this percentage is set to increase to a much less beneficial 9% by 2029/30. For the taxpayer in our example, this will cut the overall tax saving to around £1,000. The company car comeback may be short-lived after all.

The tax cost of having a company car can be calculated starting here using HMRC’s company car and car fuel benefit calculator.

Mandatory payrolling of benefits

The deadline requiring employers to report most taxable benefits through payroll software has been postponed by one year to 6 April 2027. As a result, employers can continue using form P11D to report benefits for a further year.

Once mandatory reporting is introduced, all benefits, except for employer-provided accommodation and cheap/interest-free loans, will need to be payrolled. The two exceptions can still be reported using form P11D, although the longer-term intention is that they will also come under payroll provision.

For 2026/27

Payrolling remains voluntary, and employers must register before 6 April 2026 to payroll employees’ benefits for this year. As is currently the case, it will not be possible to payroll accommodation or cheap/interest-free loans.

From 2027/28 onwards

Since payrolling will be mandatory, registration will not be necessary. Therefore:

  • Registration will be required if an employer wants to voluntarily payroll accommodation or cheap/interest-free loans.
  • The P11D process will remain in place for those employers who provide, but do not payroll, accommodation and cheap/interest-free loans.

An end-of-year process will be available to account for the values of any taxable benefits that cannot accurately be determined during the tax year. 

HMRC will automatically remove benefits from employees’ tax codes in readiness for payrolling from 6 April 2027.

Cashflow impact

The move to mandatory payrolling could see employees facing tax deducted for multiple tax years at once. With payrolling, tax is deducted in real-time, but employees could have tax collected through their tax code for benefits received in earlier years.

Should an employee face financial difficulty due to multiple tax deductions, they can request that HMRC spread the underpayment over more than one tax year.

HMRC has published a technical note providing a detailed overview of the changes from 6 April 2027, available here.