Changes made to pension relief claims

HMRC has tightened checks on pension relief after finding that a third of claims made by PAYE tax codes were incorrect.

The problem

Contributions into a personal pension are made net of basic rate tax, so only higher and additional rate taxpayers need claim relief. However, HMRC’s review found that many basic rate taxpayers were trying to claim. Claims were also made where relief had already been given through salary deduction.

To make the situation worse, some claimants had simply guessed their paid pension contributions, rather than using the information provided by their pension provider.

Claims going forward

From 1 September, it is no longer possible to make a claim over the phone; most claims must now be made online. Also:

  • Previously, taxpayers only needed to upload or send proof of pension payments made if the payments were in excess of £10,000.
  • HMRC now require all claims to be backed up with supporting evidence each tax year.
  • For personal pension contributions, this will mean a letter or statement from the pension provider showing the amount contributed.

Postal claims are only possible for those unable to claim online.

 

The changes have no impact on individuals who complete a self-assessment tax return. Claims for pension relief will continue as normal on the tax return.

Who can claim

Higher and additional rate taxpayers (in Scotland, taxpayers paying the intermediate rate or higher) paying into a personal or workplace pension can make a claim for the additional amount of tax relief for which they are entitled. For example, an additional rate taxpayer will receive a further 25% in relief.

Taxpayers can also make a claim if tax relief is not given automatically on their pension contributions.

HMRC’s guidance on claiming tax relief on pension payments can be found here.

An ominous update for pensions

Unfortunately, it’s all bad news. The government has confirmed that most unused pensions will fall within the scope of inheritance tax (IHT), and that it will review the State pension age (SPA).

On top of this comes the news that almost half of working-age adults are not making any provision for a private pension.

Unused pensions

The government has published draft legislation to take effect from 6 April 2027. The change will see most unused pension death benefits brought into charge for IHT purposes, although one change has been made in response to industry feedback. All death-in-service benefits will now be excluded from the charge to IHT.

State pension age

By March 2028, the SPA will have increased to 67. The next planned increase to age 68 is set to take place between 2044 and 2046, impacting those born on or after 6 April 1977. There have been recommendations that this timeline be brought forward, but any further changes have until now been shelved due to recent uncertainty about life expectancy.

However, with the government’s recent announcement of the next review of the SPA, further increases are possible.

Lack of pension provision

The government – not surprisingly – is very concerned about the number of people not saving privately for a pension:

  • Low earners and the self-employed are less likely to be contributing to a pension, with more than three million self-employed people without such savings.
  • The situation is worse among women and some ethnic groups.
    • Overall, some 40% of people are currently not saving enough for their retirement.

For a moderate lifestyle, it is estimated that a single person currently requires nearly £32,000 a year, with nearly £44,000 required for a couple; the full State pension is just under £12,000.

These latest findings come despite employees being automatically enrolled into pension saving. The relaunched pensions commission will therefore look at what is preventing greater pension saving, reporting back in 2027.

The currently legislated timetables for SPA can be found here.