More caught in the net of IHT property valuations

IHT

The number of property valuations challenged by HMRC has risen by more than a fifth over the past year. No surprise given that frozen inheritance tax (IHT) thresholds and higher property prices have pushed more people into the IHT net.

With residential property accounting for not far off 50% of the net value of estates, challenging valuations is an easy way for HMRC to boost tax revenues, especially as AI can now be used to identify inconsistencies.

Advice from experts

There can be significant financial consequences if an executor understates the value of property in an IHT return:

  • Apart from the additional IHT payable, late payment interest – currently set at 7.75% – will be due on the underpayment.
  • A penalty can also be charged if the underpayment results from a return containing an inaccuracy due to reasonable care not being taken.

Best advice is for executors to instruct a professional valuer, rather than just relying on an estimate from a high street estate agent. However, taking the average from three estate agent valuations will mean reasonable care has been taken.

What the future holds

Unfortunately, the situation is unlikely to improve over the next few years. IHT thresholds are set to remain frozen until 5 April 2031, while the property market, although subdued as a result of the inflationary impact of the Middle East conflict, remains resilient and is unlikely to see falling values, except for London and the South East of England.

The inclusion of most unused pension pots within the IHT net from April 2027 (unless inherited by a spouse or civil partner) will increase the number of estates subject to IHT.

Planning for your estate

Wills should be up to date, taking into account realistic property values and the coming inclusion of pension pots. Make sure that, where possible, the residence nil rate band is fully utilised as this can save IHT of £140,000 for a couple.

Lifetime gifts are becoming increasingly popular as a means to mitigate potential IHT liabilities. One problem is that the main residence might be the only sizeable asset, but downsizing could be a way of releasing funds for lifetime gifting.

The government’s guide to how to value an estate for IHT and report its value can be found here.

A light shone on the limits of the IHT gift rule

IHT

The normal expenditure out of income exemption allows individuals to make gifts during their lifetime that are immediately exempt from inheritance tax (IHT) – there is no seven-year wait. A recent case heard by the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) has cast some light on what is meant by ‘normal expenditure’.

Exemption

To be covered by the exemption, gifts must:

  • be made as part of the individual’s normal expenditure;
  • be made out of income; and
  • leave the individual with sufficient income to maintain their usual standard of living.

The income aspect might be considered straightforward, but this is not always the case. There is no statutory definition, and income is not necessarily the same as income for tax purposes. It will, for example, include non-taxable income, such as income from individual savings accounts (ISAs). HMRC considers income to become capital after it has been accumulated for a period of two years.

‘Usual standard of living’ will generally be what was usual for the individual at the time the gift was made. Exemption may, therefore, not be lost where an individual makes a regular commitment, at a time when surplus income was available, but then has to lower their standard of living for another reason, such as redundancy.

Normal expenditure

The case heard by the FTT was only concerned with whether the gifts made by the taxpayer were normal expenditure. To count as normal, gifts must be habitual or regular, but do not have to be a fixed amount.

Although the taxpayer had made many substantial charitable donations, HMRC took issue with donations to campaigns supporting the UK leaving the EU. Exemption for these donations was denied because they were made over a period of just nine months, which was not sufficient time to establish a settled pattern; there was no predictability to the donations. What is more, there was no particular reason for the financial amount given to each gift.

A settled pattern would normally mean gifts being made over three to four years, but a single gift might qualify if there is evidence that it was intended to be the first in a pattern.

Detailed guidance on the normal expenditure out of income exemption is available in HMRC’s internal manuals: IHTM14231 to IHTM14255.