Latest tax gap sets another record

tax shortfall

The tax gap for 2024/25 sets another record at £59.2 billion, with small businesses accounting for some 62% of the taxes not collected.

The tax gap is the difference between the amount of tax that should, in theory, be paid to HMRC, and what is actually paid.

Upward trend

The tax gap for 2024/25 represents around 6.4% of the total tax due. Although the tax gap has been higher historically, it has generally increased throughout recent years; for example, for 2021/22, it was 5.7%.

HMRC, as is normally the case, has revised figures for previous years. When figures were released for 2023/24, the tax gap was shown as generally declining. However, the latest figures show the tax gap for 2023/24 at 6.0%, rather than the previous 5.3%, an increase of £6 billion.

Small businesses under scrutiny

In 2024/25, small businesses accounted for 62% of the tax gap, an increase of four percentage points since 2020/21. Such firms are the main culprits here, with HMRC estimating that around 45% of the corporation tax owed was not collected. No surprise then that identity verification has recently been introduced for company directors and persons with significant control.

Behaviour

The largest proportion of the tax gap comes from failure to take reasonable care. This is currently 35% – nearly £21 billion – increasing from 30% of the tax gap in 2020/21:

  • HMRC blames failure to take reasonable care on a taxpayer’s carelessness, negligence, or poor record-keeping, but the increasing complexity of the tax system and the deterioration in HMRC customer service also play a part.
  • Add in taxpayer errors and more than half of the tax gap is now down to taxpayers who probably regard themselves as tax-compliant.

Actual evasion of tax only accounts for 12% of the tax gap, with tax avoidance standing at just 1% of the total. HMRC’s summary details of the latest tax gap figures can be found here.

Business rates cuts for leisure businesses

leisure

Owners of public houses have faced significantly higher bills for business rates from April 2026. To partly offset the increases, the government announced a 15% discount for the current year and has recently announced a 20% discount for 2027/28.

The higher business rates costs have been generated as a result of a business rates revaluation and the removal of Covid-era relief.

Who qualifies?

For 2025/26, retail, hospitality and leisure businesses in England qualified for a 40% discount on their business rates:

  • The 15% and 20% discounts are more restrictive, only applying for public houses, clubs and live music venues. The discounts are applied on top of any other available reliefs.
  • Not surprisingly, owners of restaurants, cafés and hotels are disappointed about their exclusion from the latest discounts.
  • Larger live music venues will not qualify for the 20% discount, with further details expected to be outlined in the Autumn Budget.

Almost 32,000 public houses, clubs and live music venues are likely to benefit from the 15% and 20% discounts, with the typical public house expected to save £1,100 in 2027/28.

For 2026/27, Scotland has given a 15% discount for retail, hospitality and leisure businesses, and Wales provides a similar discount for food and drink hospitality businesses.

Support for small businesses

For premises in England, 100% relief applies where the rateable value is less than £12,000, with tapered relief for properties valued up to £15,000.

Most English properties which have lost the retail, hospitality and leisure discount qualify for the Supporting Small Business Relief (SSBR) scheme. The calculations can be complicated, but, for example, the business rates rise for 2026/27 for a property with a rateable value between £20,001 (£28,001 in London) and £100,000 is capped at the higher of £800 and 15%. Caps also apply for 2027/28 and 2028/29.

However, for public houses, clubs and live music venues, their business rates bill will only increase by inflation for 2027/28 and 2028/29, with the newly announced 20% discount in addition to this cap.

Details of the 15% discount for 2026/27 can be found here.

Enterprise management incentives grow in popularity

Enterprise management

The April 2026 enterprise management incentive (EMI) reforms have pushed this perk towards mainstream acceptance. Higher qualifying limits mean that EMI tax-advantaged share options can now continue to be granted even as a company grows and matures.

EMIs help to retain and reward key people. They can be granted options at a price agreed at the outset, and which can be exercised at a set time or if a performance target is hit. The maximum market value of unexercised EMI share options that an employee can hold in a three-year period is £250,000.

Tax advantages

There is generally no tax charge when EMI share options are granted to an employee or when options are exercised. A capital gains tax liability can arise when the shares are sold, but the gain will potentially qualify for a flat rate of 18%.

Qualifying limits

The following limits apply to EMI contracts granted since 6 April 2026:

  • The maximum market value of unexercised EMI options granted by a company cannot exceed £6 million (previously £3 million).
  • Gross assets must be less than £120 million, with fewer than 500 full-time equivalent employees (previously £30 million and 250 employees).
  • The maximum exercise period for EMI options is 15 years (previously 10 years).

Companies can retrospectively apply the 15-year exercise period to EMI share option contracts previously granted.

Company considerations:

  • Companies which have not previously qualified for EMI should review whether they now qualify, and whether EMI options are the right choice for future employee equity incentives.
  • Similar considerations apply if a company has previously qualified, but then exceeded the gross assets or employee limits as the company has grown; or the company has hit the old £3 million limit for unexercised EMI options.
  • Companies with existing EMI options should decide whether they want to extend the exercise period to 15 years.

Details on EMIs (along with other employee share schemes) can be found here.