VAT return errors get an update

value added tax

HMRC have withdrawn form VAT652. Companies with large VAT return errors must now submit corrections online or in writing. Larger VAT return errors are entered as method 2 type corrections, whereas method 1 is used when correcting smaller errors.

Method 1

Smaller VAT return errors can be corrected by making adjustments to the current VAT return. This is known as method 1, and it can be used where:

  • The net error (along with any errors in the previous four years) total less than £10,000. For example, if output VAT has been underpaid by £11,000, but input VAT has been underclaimed by £2,000, then the net error is £9,000 and can be corrected using method 1; or
  • The net error is between £10,000 and £50,000, and also less than 1% of the output figure for the current VAT return. So, if outputs are £2.5 million, a net error of up to £25,000 can be corrected using method 1. For most businesses, however, only the £10,000 limit will be relevant.

Late payment interest will not be charged, and, provided reasonable care has been taken, there will not be a penalty.

Method 2

With the withdrawal of form VAT652, errors that are too large for method 1 to be used must now be corrected online; although it is also possible to notify HMRC in writing. This is method 2, which will incur a late payment interest charge. Companies notifying HMRC of a large VAT return error must include information about how it happened and across which VAT period(s).

Penalties

A penalty will be charged if an error has been made as a result of being careless, or where the error is due to deliberate behaviour. A careless error can still be corrected using method 1, although HMRC must also be informed of the error. A deliberate error must always be corrected using method 2.

HMRC’s guidance on correcting for VAT errors can be found here.

The stamp duty tangle – a useful lesson

The former Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner’s recent problems with stamp duty land tax (SDLT) offer a salutary lesson. 

In early September, the Deputy Prime Minister (and Housing Secretary) resigned after discovering that she had underpaid SDLT by £40,000 on the purchase of a flat in Hove.

That Rayner missed the history of the additional tax liability was unfortunately ironic. The surcharge on stamp duty was introduced by Conservative Chancellor, George Osborne, in the Autumn Statement 2015, at a rate of 3%. It took effect from April 2016, and the rate was subsequently increased to 5% nine years later in the Autumn Budget presented by Angela Rayner’s then cabinet colleague, Rachel Reeves.   

The tax aimed to discourage buy-to-let and second home purchasers, who were often shopping for similar properties to first-time buyers in a pressured housing market. The basis of the additional tax required the buyer to pay extra SDLT if they owned another residential property on the same day that another property was bought. That might sound simple enough, but the legislation to achieve it was not, involving the closure of potential loopholes, such as buying the second property through a company or using trusts to shift ownership.

It was the latter anti-avoidance measure which tripped up Angela Rayner. She had sold the 25% interest in her first home, in Ashton-under-Lyne, to a trust for the benefit of her disabled child before buying her Hove apartment. Paragraph 12 of Schedule 4ZA of the Finance Act 2003 deemed that such a sale meant that Rayner was still treated as owning the property for SDLT purposes.

While Rayner had sought guidance on her SDLT position, the advice she received was qualified by the acknowledgement that it did not constitute expert tax advice and was accompanied by a suggestion, or in one case a recommendation, that specific tax advice be obtained. Had Rayner paid heed to those warnings, she would not now be facing a potential tax penalty of up to £12,000 for ‘carelessness’, in addition to the £40,000 extra SDLT.

The lesson of the whole episode and one to keep in mind whenever advice – particularly in the financial area – is needed: make sure you are talking to an expert who stands behind their judgement.

The government guide to SLDT is here.