Breaking the (tax) code

More than 5.6 million employees were issued the wrong tax code last year, resulting in £3.5 billion in tax overpaid to HMRC. Reclaiming overpayments, however, can be a slow and frustrating process.

Typical problems

Often, problems arise because HMRC has made a best estimate of someone’s income:

  • Taxable benefits: Benefits such as a company car, healthcare or gym membership may no longer be received, but HMRC will be unaware of such changes.
  • Additional income: HMRC will base their estimate of additional income on what an employee made the previous year, but the income – such as property letting, dividends, or freelance work – may be less or have ceased altogether. Again, HMRC will be unaware of this change.
  • Multiple employments: Holding several jobs, especially where a job only lasts for a few months, will invariably lead to incorrect tax coding.
  • Allowances: The tax code could suggest an incorrect level of income when it comes to the amount of available personal allowance.
  • Allowable expenses: Deductions for subscriptions and professional fees will be based on what was previously claimed, yet these will invariably increase each year.

Check tax codes

The responsibility to report an incorrect tax code lies with the employee. Correcting mistakes immediately avoids having to reclaim overpaid tax. This can mean a long wait, with HMRC providing a poor telephone service and often ignoring written requests:

  • The fact that paper tax code notices are no longer routinely issued means that a bit more effort is required to check HMRC’s coding assumptions.
  • Employees should update details on the HMRC app or their online personal tax account.

Once details are updated, HMRC will amend the tax code and inform the employer within 15 working days. Unless changes are made towards the end of the tax year, any tax refund should automatically be made by the employer.

The government’s guide to tax codes can be found here.

Don’t fall into the communication gap on Making Tax Digital

Many potentially affected taxpayers have not yet engaged with a major change in tax reporting.

Communication is arguably not one of HMRC’s strongest points. While its requests for tax returns are made within the start of the tax year, it is not so prompt in other areas. The latest HMRC performance statistics, issued in January 2026, reveal that between January to November 2025:

  • More than one-in-five pieces of correspondence had not received a reply within 15 working days, and one-in-eight was still languishing unanswered after 40 working days.
  • The average speed of answering a telephone call exceeded 13 minutes, with over one-in-ten calls being abandoned.

Poor communication created problems when the high income child benefit charge (HICBC) was introduced in 2013. It was not until September 2025 that HMRC finally launched an online service allowing those affected to pay the charge via pay as you earn (PAYE), rather than completing an income tax self assessment return.

Now, another reform to the tax system is due to start from April and threatens to meet a similar I-didn’t-know-about-that response to the one that dogged the HICBC for years. The new change is the requirement to report certain income under the Making Tax Digital (MTD) rules.

Initially, MTD will affect those who:

  • are personally registered for self assessment,
  • receive income from self-employment or property (or both), and
  • had qualifying income (basically gross income from self-employment and property) of more than £50,000 in 2024/25.

If you meet those three criteria, then you must:

  • Sign up for MTD – HMRC will not automatically register you, although it will send chase-up letters,
  • Acquire HMRC-recognised software or, if you stick with spreadsheets or your existing software, obtain ‘bridging software’ that works with HMRC systems,
  • Send quarterly updates of your income and expenses to HMRC, and
  • Send an end-of-year return by 31 January following the end of the tax year.

It is perhaps indicative of HMRC’s expectations that in the Autumn 2025 Budget it was announced that taxpayers will not receive penalty points for late submission of quarterly updates for 2026/27.

If you are thinking, “Phew, I am under the £50,000 threshold”, the bad news is that it falls to £30,000 for 2027/28 and £20,000 thereafter.

Find out if you need to make your tax digital on the government website here.

.