Spring Statement: The magic of £9.9 billion

There were no tax increases in the Chancellor’s Spring Statement (upgraded from an initial Spring Forecast), but that might just be pain deferred.

Before becoming Chancellor, Rachel Reeves set out a new goal for the public finances, now badged the ‘Stability Rule’. In simple terms, this requires the Government should at least match its day-to-day expenditure with what it receives in tax and other revenue. In 2024/25, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) projects there will be a shortfall under this rule (technically a current budget account deficit) of £60.7 billion. Following past government tradition of fiscal targets, the Chancellor has set a five-year goal taking us to 2029/30.

When Rachel Reeves presented her Budget last October, the OBR projected that she would meet her Stability Rule with £9.9 billion to spare. However five months later, the OBR recalculated the margin (often called headroom) in preparation for the Spring Statement and concluded that, with no changes, the Rule would be missed by £4.1 billion – a £14 billion reversal.

Given that the margin of £9.9 billion (about 0.7% of total government expenditure) proved inadequate last time, it is surprising that the new headroom figure is also £9.9 billion. This is despite the raft of Spring Statement measures – mostly spending cuts. The apparent circularity of the Spring Statement process has prompted speculation that the large cuts to welfare benefits were tailored to fit the Stability Rule, rather than wholly founded in encouraging more people into work.

The problem with maintaining a small £9.9 billion headroom is that when the OBR’s next assessment arrives in the autumn, there is a similar risk of missing the Stability Rule once again. The OBR’s judgement day will coincide with the Chancellor’s one ‘fiscal event’ of the year – the Autumn Budget. A second miss would probably see Reeves turn to tax increases rather than more spending cuts to recover the situation.

There were already signs of preparation for such a move in the Spring Statement. For example, hidden in the main document was a comment about reviewing the balance between cash and shares in Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs). Reducing the amount that could be placed in cash ISAs would yield extra revenue, because it would mean less tax relief being given. 

It seems likely that, as happened in 2024, speculation about tax rises will get underway before summer begins. Taking time to focus on your financial planning over the next few months could be more important than ever. You have been warned.

What to expect from the Spring Forecast on 26 March

The Chancellor has announced the timing of her next formal report to Parliament.

Cast your mind back six Chancellors ago to Philip Hammond (aka Spreadsheet Phil). In autumn 2016, Hammond announced a change to the timings of Budget announcements, with a Spring Budget and Autumn Pre-Budget Report (PBR) to be replaced by an Autumn Budget and a Spring Statement. His aim was to move away from what had virtually become two Budgets a year, with the PBR introducing as many – if not more – tax changes than the real thing.

The new scheduling was welcomed by the likes of the Institute for Government, but fell victim to events, notably general elections and the Covid-19 pandemic. Since 2017, there have been as many Spring Budgets as Autumn Budgets and in one year (2022) when there was only (and notoriously) one unofficial mini-Budget presented by Kwasi Kwarteng. In her March 2024 Mais Lecture, Rachel Reeves made clear that were she to become Chancellor she would revert to Hammond’s schedule and have only one major ‘fiscal event’ each year, that is, an Autumn Budget.

That still leaves a Spring statement of some sort, not least because the Office of Budget Responsibility (OBR) is required by law to produce two reports each fiscal year on the state of the economy and the government’s finances. Shortly before Christmas, the Treasury announced that the 2025 ‘Spring Forecast’ would be presented to Parliament on 26 March, the day that the OBR’s report is to be published.

While the accompanying press release did not rule out any tax changes in March, it did say, “The Chancellor remains committed to one major fiscal event a year to give families and businesses stability and certainty on upcoming tax and spending changes”. Those words and the continued debate from last October’s Budget both point to no new tax measures being revealed on 26 March, even if the OBR numbers are disappointing. However, in January this year, after government borrowing costs rose, rumours were beginning to appear that spending cuts were in the offing.

The probable absence of tax changes is good news as we enter the season of planning for the tax year end and the start of a new tax year. The £40 billion of tax increases in autumn last year can only mean that tax year planning is particularly important for 2025. 

The Autumn Budget – a brave new tax world

Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ first Budget was a significant one in all senses.

“…this Budget delivers a large, sustained increase in spending, taxation, and borrowing.”

So said the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) in the first paragraph of its overview of the Autumn Budget. The numbers are indeed large:

  • spending is up by almost £70 billion a year over the next five years;
  • taxation will rise by £36 billion a year; and
  • borrowing will still be above £70 billion a year in 2029/30.

The Chancellor’s tax-raising opportunities were constrained by the Labour manifesto pledges to hold the rates of income tax, VAT, corporation tax and national insurance contributions (NICs) – only for employees, although other interpretations are available. The result was that other taxes had to carry the burden of providing extra funds for the Treasury:

  • Over half the additional revenue came from changes to employer’s NICs from 2025/26. These saw the class 1 employer rate rise from 13.8% to 15.0%, and the starting point for payments fall from £9,100 of annual earnings to £5,000. The impact of this was mitigated slightly by a £5,500 increase to £10,500 in the employment allowance – effectively an employer NIC credit.
  • The main capital gains tax rates have increased from 10% to 18% (for non-taxpayers and basic rate taxpayers) and from 20% to 24% (for higher and additional rate taxpayers). The rate for business assets disposal relief will rise from 10% to 14% in 2025/26 and then 18% in the following tax year, with the maximum amount of lifetime relievable gain staying at £1 million.
  • Inheritance tax (IHT) relief for businesses and agricultural property will be cut back from April 2026, with the relief for qualifying shares listed on the Alternative Investment Market halved to 50%.
  • Death benefits from pensions will be brought into IHT from 2027/28, although there were none of the other tax changes that had been rumoured in the weeks before the Budget. Notably full income tax relief on contributions remains and employer contributions continue to be free of NICs.

If you could be affected by any of these changes (or further changes not mentioned in this update), make sure that you seek advice. The sooner you are prepared for this new, higher tax environment, the better.