Taxpayer Protection Taskforce to tackle Covid-19 fraud

A recent report by the public accounts committee estimates that the level of fraud and error across all Covid-19 support schemes could be as high as £20 billion. However, don’t assume mistakes and errors will not be picked up – HMRC is running the Taxpayer Protection Taskforce (Taskforce) to scrutinise claims made.

The two main areas of concern are the furlough scheme with an expected loss through fraud of £5.3 billion, and the bounce back loan scheme with some £18 billion expected to be written off.

Scrutiny

The Taskforce was set up a year ago and will likely be in place until March 2023. The Covid-19 support schemes to be scrutinised by the Taskforce include:

  • The furlough scheme;
  • Self-employment income support schemes;
  • Eat out to help out; and
  • Bounce back and business Interruption loans.

Some of the enquiries made by the Taskforce will be completely random, but many will be in response to information received by HMRC. The Taskforce anticipates making some 30,000 enquiries in total. 

For example, from December 2020, details of furlough claims made by employers were published online. Employees could therefore report suspicions of fraudulent claims, and HMRC intends to look at every report made.

One example of compliance action highlighted by HMRC was a business that had claimed to have furloughed all of their workforce for two months. However, an analysis of card sales data showed no drop-off in trade for these two months.

Errors and mistakes

HMRC is fully aware that errors and mistakes may have been made given the pressure that business owners were under during the pandemic. Fully furloughed staff may have ended up doing some work, or the conditions for a self-employment income support scheme grant weren’t met.

Individuals and companies can use HMRC’s online disclosure service to rectify any errors or mistakes made. Voluntary disclosure is preferable to HMRC finding out for themselves.

The starting point for HMRC’s disclosure service can be found here.

What is ‘substantial extent’ for non-trading activities?

Gains that qualify for business asset disposal relief (BADR) are taxed at a reduced rate of 10%, but relief for company shares is not available if the underlying company carries on substantial non-trading activities. HMRC has long applied a strict 20% test, but a recent Upper Tribunal case has forced HMRC to backpedal and further clarify the interpretation of ‘substantial’.

In Assem Allam vs. HMRC [2021] UKUT 0291, the Upper Tribunal found that previous HMRC guidance using a simple 80/20 test of trading versus non-trading activity is not always going to produce the correct answer when deciding if the relief is available. HMRC guidance has not completely done away with the 20% test, but less emphasis is now placed on it.

 

In any dispute with HMRC, it is important to remember that a decision of the Upper Tribunal makes the law, but HMRC guidance does not have the force of law.

Upper Tribunal approach

The Upper Tribunal concluded that the legislation does not provide for a strict numeric test. The test of whether non-trading activities are substantial is a holistic one not confined to physical human activity, but requires an overall consideration of what it is that the company does.

Other factors than those listed in HMRC’s guidance can also be relevant.

HMRC guidance

HMRC’s revised guidance now states that the 20% test is only likely to be relevant when considering the level of non-trading income and the value of a company’s non-trading assets. If neither exceed 20%, HMRC will generally accept that the relief is available without further enquiry.

  • Also relevant is the proportion of expenses spent on non-trading activities, as well as the amount of time and resources incurred.
  • The relevant factors should be considered over a company’s history, not just at one point in time; particularly if trade is seasonal.

Having investment property may therefore preclude claiming BADR. However, there is a bit more leeway when it comes to a large cash balance because it may be argued out of the equation as being required for trading purposes.

HMRC’s guidance on the meaning of ‘substantial’ can be found here within their capital gains manual.