Tax Relief for Owner-Managers

There is no certainty of all the measures surviving, but September’s Growth Plan was good news as far as tax is concerned for owner-managers, with the rates of corporation tax, national insurance contributions (NICs) and dividend tax all cut.

The cuts

  • Corporation tax: The intended increase in the main rate of corporation tax to 25% for profits in excess of £250,000 from 1 April 2023 has been cancelled. A marginal rate of 26.5% would have applied to profits between £50,000 and £250,000. Corporation tax will now remain at the current single rate of 19%.
  • NICs: The 1.25% health and social care levy has been cancelled, so the rates of NICs for 2023/24 will return to what they were for 2021/22. For directors, the rate will be 12% on remuneration between £12,570 and £50,270, with a 2% rate thereafter. For the company, a flat rate of 13.8%. Compared to 2021/22, however, the increased primary threshold has been retained – a double benefit.
  • Dividend tax: Tax rates for 2023/24 will similarly be cut by 1.25%, meaning a basic rate of 7.5%, a higher rate of 32.5% and an additional rate of 38.1%.

Directors will also benefit from the proposed 1% cut to the basic rate of income tax from 6 April 2023.

Impact

The changes previously set to come in from April 2023 would have made incorporation much less attractive compared to running an unincorporated business. The Growth Plan tax cuts effectively return the tax position to what it was for 2021/22. For a business with profits of £100,000 (taking director’s remuneration of £12,570 and maximum dividends if run as a limited company), the tax cost comparison – before and after the tax cuts for 2023/24 – is:

 

Unincorporated

Incorporated

Advantage

Before tax cuts

£33,100

£33,000

£100

After tax cuts

£31,600

£30,300

£1,300

The government’s step by step guide on setting up a limited company can be found here.

IR35 Rollback Surprise

One of the least expected announcements in the Chancellor’s recent Growth Plan was the rollback of the IR35 off-payroll working rules to the position prior to the 2017 and 2021 reforms, which is set to take effect from 6 April 2023.

The 2017 and 2021 reforms moved responsibility for status determination from the contractor to the client, be it in the private (2021 reform) or public (2017 reform) sector. The one exception was when working for a small private sector client where responsibility remained with the contractor.

If caught under the off-payroll working rules, the contractor has been taxed as an employee with income tax and national insurance contributions (NICs) deducted.

The repeal of the 2017 and 2021 reforms is currently just the government’s intent and is not guaranteed until the next Finance Bill reaches Royal Assent – something far from assured given the political climate.

Rollback rules from 6 April 2023

Contractors providing their services via an intermediary company (or partnership) will once again be responsible for determining their own employment status.

  • If a contract is deemed to be outside the off-payroll working rules, the contractor can simply withdraw the income on the most favourable tax basis, or it can be left undrawn in the company.
  • If within the rules, the contractor will be responsible for calculating income tax and NICs, and then paying these over to HMRC.

Although there a very strict deadline for complying with the tax obligations if caught under the rules, one advantage is that a 5% flat rate expense deduction is given when calculating the income to be taxed.

Clients who have implemented a blanket ban on using company contractors are likely to reverse their position, with the contracting market revitalised. However, this will probably not happen immediately, with both contractors and clients needing time to adjust to the new status quo.

HMRC’s guidance on the current off-payroll working rules, which continue to apply until 5 April 2023, can be found here.

Making Tax Digital: Avoiding VAT Penalties

From 1 November 2022, VAT-registered businesses that do not yet comply with the Making Tax Digital (MTD) requirements will face penalties. Businesses should also be aware of the new VAT penalty regime being introduced from 1 January 2023.

Although VAT-registered business should already be submitting their VAT returns using MTD compatible software, they have until now been able to continue using their VAT online account without incurring a penalty. However, for those businesses filing their VAT returns monthly or quarterly, this option will no longer be available, making it impossible to file other than by using MTD software.

HMRC has said that a business filing annual VAT returns can continue to use their VAT online account until 15 May 2023.

Around 10% of businesses filing returns using the correct MTD software have not yet signed up for MTD with HMRC but will need to do so to avoid a penalty.

Penalties

The maximum penalty for filing a VAT return using the incorrect method is £400, but only £100 if a business’s turnover is below £100,000.

Any business that is not signed up for MTD will also be at risk of incurring penalties under the new regime applicable for VAT return periods beginning on or after 1 January 2023:

  • Interest, currently set at 4.75%, will be charged from the due date.
  • Late payment penalties will kick in, initially at 2% of the outstanding VAT, once payment is more than 15 days late.
  • Late submission penalties will be charged under a points-based system, with an initial £200 penalty charged if four quarterly returns are late.


Having a reasonable excuse might provide a potential escape route, but failure to use MTD software is hardly likely to count.

HMRC’s guidance on how to avoid penalties for MTD for VAT can be found here.